Harold Garfinkel’s s case study of “Agnes” is broadly understood as the locus classicus of sociological research about transgender peo- ple. Drawing on an. Agnes was a year old woman with an accidental penis appendage. Studied by anthropologist Harold Garfinkel and written about in a The paper was written by one Dr. Garfinkel and his experience treating a patient called Agnes, whom he first met in November of Agnes.

Author: Goltira Mikat
Country: Venezuela
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Politics
Published (Last): 7 May 2005
Pages: 142
PDF File Size: 7.48 Mb
ePub File Size: 5.76 Mb
ISBN: 443-1-49298-506-8
Downloads: 42273
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Melkree

Agnes wanted to get treatment for what she regarded as a very problematic condition. In London, through my mentor, I met older patients from various backgrounds, but it was decades before I encountered, through the Net, anyone who had had been a child like me and had surgery at he same sort of age.

There was some evidence of female hormonal activity, however.

Agnes Torres

She saw her own masculine sexuality as an error, and claimed that her case was unusually difficult to understand. Views Read Edit View history.

As far as I know, Agnes is still a controversial figure. Five years after her surgery and consultation sessions had finished, Agnes returned to catch up with the doctors who had helped her. It is essential that action is routinised, and this means taking much about social order on trust.

You are commenting using your Twitter account. June 22, at Whilst she was no longer with Bill, none of the men she had been with sexually since him garfinksl ever given any reason to think they found her in any way out of the ordinary. Agnes, born in with male physical attributes and assigned male at birth, knew herself to be female.

Reposted from Shakesville with permission from both Blogger: You are commenting using your Facebook account.

gxrfinkel She had no interest in waging a political fight, or in challenging any aspect of social norms. The only surgeon that she could have been referred to, as a transsexual patient, would have been in Borou in Casablanca, Morocco, North Africa — an impossible dream for a girl of her economic class in the days before cheap travel. She was aware that she was managing what others were taking for granted but not just in the Goffman sense of management of impressions — there were definite elements of unknown consequences and goals, risks, the absence of clear rules, and thus a necessary unremitting improvisation, and a constant requirement to explain herself.


June 19, at 1: In this way, she saw her ability to manage her identity as confirming her subjectivity as a ‘real gadfinkel valuable person’ The nineteen year old Agnes was the youngest gafinkel four children, supported by her mother who worked in an aircraft plant. She spoke in generalities and impersonal terms, feigned misunderstanding, and practiced ‘legalism’ [involving a strategically literal interpretation of words].

By the end of the show, the formerly drab something has been made into a Va-Va Voom hourglass model in garfin,el bright purple dress and honey-colored tresses. Plus, all the cool qids are into faux-alliteration these days. Please feel free to pick it apart in your own delicious, juicy minds. You are commenting using your Twitter account. AGom on American Motherhood.

People in the clinic had to achieve the right to medical treatment, to avoid stigma, and then learn to relate to other people in their new sex status. The paper was written by one Dr.

She let the others take the lead in conversation to see which way the wind was blowing –‘permitting the environment to teach varfinkel the answers that it agnees to its own questions’ She was surprised by the angry reaction of her boyfriend when she sunbathed in public, or acted inappropriately in company — she used these occasions to learn about appropriate female behaviour. This helped her to claim that it was impossible to generalise from her experience to include other transfers — she claimed to be unique.

She was agrfinkel in Portland, Oregonand found to have XY chromosomes, and neither a uterus nor the hypothesized tumor that might produce estrogen.

At garrfinkel, she began dressing and acting as the woman that she knew herself garfinkek be. Elmer Belt in gartinkel same time frame roughly as Agnes. By the early Dr. Those 10 years made a major difference in other ways. Further those of us who came out 10 years or so after Agnes were better educated as to what was there and had greater knowledge of others.


She was raised Catholic, but no longer believed in God. She did not know what the effects would be, only that this was a female substance, and she had no idea how much to take but more or less tried to follow the amounts her mother took.

The original chapter can be read here at least in partthrough Google books. There had been another source of suspicion that she had induced female characteristics by taking female hormones, and that she had permitted frequent anal intercourse.

In contrast, she now revealed that just as puberty began, at the time her voice started to lower and she developed public hair, she began stealing Stilbestrol from her mother, who was taking it on prescription following a panhysterectomy.

I put this in inverted commas because this was the term Dr.

Agnes Torres – Wikipedia

I almost went to him but was intimidated by potential language issues with the Spanish speaking nursing staff and my order in restaurants ask where the bathroom is etc level of Spanish. Certainly hormone replacement therapy seemed to cure many of the post operative problems.

The homophobic and transphobic side of Agnes certainly makes me cringe. It is clear that Agnes was also passing with the researchers [it seems like some psychologists were involved too], for example by asking to complete the psychological tests at home. She was offered a sex-change operation, involving castration and the partial reconstruction of female genitalia. The learning process continued for decades, and maybe still does, although agnea seem unchanged in the lsst 5 years.

Retrieved from ” https: Agnex living people Place of birth missing. She did so deliberately, and recognised it as a device.

If she had to lie to a bunch of liars, fair enough. Create a free website or blog at WordPress.